Fighter Pilots are Battle Managers

Interview with Jeff “Cobra” Harrigian, Lockheed Martin

Shownotes

His career in the U.S. Air Force spanned nearly four decades. Our guest on this podcast episode ist Jeff “Cobra” Harrigian. He is a retired U.S. Air Force general, who flew the F-22 and F-15, among other aircraft. His military career included commanding U.S. Air Forces in Europe and Africa, as well as NATO’s Allied Air Command. Now, Cobra leads strategy and business development at Lockheed Martin’s Skunk Works.

Podcast host Stefan Tesch talks with “Cobra” about:

  • Why are pilots now battle managers?
  • Air defence: How has the situation changed over the last decade?
  • How important is data exchange between European countries?
  • What role do CCAs play in air forces?

About Militär Aktuell

Upcoming events:

Transkript anzeigen

00:00:02: Militia Actuell, the podcast on military and security.

00:00:08: His career in US Air Force spent nearly four decades!

00:00:13: Our guest for this episode is Jeff Cobra Harigian.

00:00:18: He's a retired air force general who flew F-twenty two and the F-fifteen among other aircraft.

00:00:25: his military career included commanding U.S.

00:00:29: Air Forces in Europe and Africa as well as NATO's Allied Air Command.

00:00:35: Now, Cobra leads strategy and business development at Lockheed Martin's Skunk Works.

00:00:41: My name is Stefan Tesch And let's get straight into our interview with him which we recorded remotely.

00:00:49: So you're looking back on a career of thirty seven years in the air force.

00:00:55: What was the reason why have you joined the Air Force?

00:00:59: Well I joined the airforce largely too fly fighter airplanes.

00:01:04: I had some experiences growing up where while my dad did not have a job, he was a pilot...I got to fly often with him and um i'll never forget it was uh..i think my eighth birthday.

00:01:20: we were flying from Honolulu to San Francisco And I get in the front seat of an airplane talk to Los Angeles center.

00:01:30: All I wanted to do was fly.

00:01:32: And so, I was fortunate to have an opportunity To go the United States Air Force Academy which set me up well too then Go to pilot training and ultimately achieve my dream of getting into fighter aircraft and Frankly while i wanted to join to fly it became bigger than that you know?

00:01:56: You get work with people that are your lifelong friends and great partners, And you build a team in camaraderie.

00:02:05: That's frankly unmatched anything You can do.

00:02:09: so I was fortunate to be able To fly all the way through my career as three-star even A little bit of four star.

00:02:19: So i'm thankful for The opportunity.

00:02:22: I

00:02:24: can understand.

00:02:25: So now you're working for Lockheed Mart and your responsible for the Skank Works program?

00:02:29: Could you be so kind of give us a short overview?

00:02:32: what is this skank works Program exactly?

00:02:35: yeah, well i think first it's uh You know.

00:02:37: some people ask me Uh, you know why did you you know just kind of retire for good?

00:02:42: And might he end up going to lockheed?

00:02:44: and so part of that was um I felt like as they say in English, you know.

00:02:49: I still had a little gas left in the tank and i wanted to continue To help not only my nation In our air force but i think uh The time that i had um in europe And then the middle east demonstrated there was Still plenty of work to be done?

00:03:07: As i came to Lockheedin Was offered an opportunity to Work with this skunkworks team Of which has, you're probably familiar.

00:03:15: You know I was very early in on the F-twenty two program and had several opportunities to work with people from Skunk Works and knew the incredible talent that uh...was there.

00:03:30: And as you look at the history of skunk works it goes all way back to nineteen forty three In World War II and Kelly Johnson being offered an opportunity which at the time was the Army Air Corps, but it was really... The challenges that we as a United States were having during World War II with the German

00:03:52: ME-U.S.,

00:03:53: and so he was challenged to build an airplane inside of one hundred eighty days And you actually had the XP-Eighty flying in one hundred forty three days.

00:04:04: So Skunk Works has always worked to develop and field And I won't just say airplanes, but you know if you think about the ecosystem of platforms and those things that support Platforms.

00:04:21: That's what skunkworks does and they do it at speed in a way that they're able to prototype Leverage new technology and then quickly take back technology and bring it into the the platforms or the The ecosystem of capabilities that get after urgent operational needs for our nation.

00:04:44: And I say that because while we largely work with the Air Force, we also look for opportunities to connect beyond just the air domain but into other domains where we can now leverage that technology to make the joint force better.

00:04:58: and i think that Skunkworks mentality and desire to stay close so the customer understand those needs is really what drew me to Skunk Works and has inspired me to continue this work as we move forward, doing it not only inside the US but importantly for our international partners that were working with every day now.

00:05:23: How would you describe how air defense changed within last ten years?

00:05:30: That's a great question!

00:05:33: I grew up like most fighter pilots focused on the tactical edge and what we would do in a particular airplane.

00:05:42: You know, I spent a lot of time on F-F-T and then as i highlighted ,I went to the f-twenty two And in particular .i saw how the F-Twenty Two took us from not just um you know being the pilot inside the airplane that managed What was going on with our sensors but more broadly?

00:05:59: How you turn into an I would call it more of a battle manager, in particular as an F-twenty two pilot where now the airplane is doing a lot of work for you.

00:06:11: And so if you think about the maturity and how the weapon system has evolved.

00:06:16: that also impacted what's happened from an air defense perspective particularly in the last ten years.

00:06:23: i think we all acknowledge that threats have evolved changed um...in many different ways.

00:06:32: Recently and in particular over the last, you know five years or so we've seen the growth of drones.

00:06:39: And The impact that is had Frankly from a global perspective.

00:06:44: You I like to remind folks That when i was the commander In the Middle East?

00:06:54: They were typically smaller drones that they were putting grenades on and targeting forces on the ground, potentially impacting some of our air bases.

00:07:10: That has grown into what we've seen not only in the Middle East but also from the Russians with respect to this drone technology coming-in at a low cost.

00:07:24: that has changed the dynamic with respect to not only the tactical techniques and procedures that are used, but operationally.

00:07:33: how do we build a layered defense?

00:07:35: That it not only defends the theater ballistic missiles you know.

00:07:39: The high altitude ones that uh... We have generally focused on But also take.

00:07:47: recognize that's still a threat, but now look to ensure we're executing air defense against these significant numbers of drones.

00:07:55: That bring it...a different problem set not only to us tactically but also operationally and I would probably drive that as the biggest change that happened over the last couple years.

00:08:07: So what are their bigger things pilots have to face?

00:08:12: Yeah, well so if you look at the problem set from that from the pilots perspective You know we grew up largely having a I would say From a Western Air Force perspective an advantage with our technology with our training and The way that we went out and Executed not only the air defense mission but I would call it airpower writ large.

00:08:41: And so, as those threats have evolved we've had to not only adapt that threat from a tactics techniques and procedures perspective

00:08:53: i.e.,

00:08:54: how would UNI operate together has set of two airplanes four planes or even larger numbers but now take into account the fact We are dealing with a significantly, or the potential to deal with significantly increased weapons ranges.

00:09:14: Some of them using new techniques from an infrared I'll call it up passive type threat too.

00:09:24: now that the numbers we're facing this drone technology is out there.

00:09:29: so if i could categorize in broad perspective would be much more complex.

00:09:35: There's increased numbers, and we've had to adjust not only the way that we build the air defense architecture

00:09:44: i.e.,

00:09:45: the layer defense that would be used first find-and-fix where threats are then how do you employ them?

00:09:55: Not just from the air layer but also potentially integrating with guys in the surface shooting at endgame threats or even using some of our maritime capabilities to support this broader air defense architecture that has become so important, everything we do as nations.

00:10:14: To defend.

00:10:16: you know our populations and infrastructure in those types things.

00:10:21: So when you look at Europe's air defence what concerns your most?

00:10:28: you know, having had an opportunity to spend several years over there and work inside a NATO with the air components across Europe.

00:10:39: And that would include all of the nations not just the NATO nations.

00:10:42: I will applaud first effort they are taking focus on.

00:10:47: problem set occurred in last couple.

00:10:53: The threats have evolved and the way that they are leveraging some of these capabilities has changed.

00:11:00: And, the nations are now adapting to that.

00:11:03: Clearly as you've heard... ...the General Grinkiewicz from NATO talk about some of the hybrid attacks and I would call it some of the asymmetric things that the Russians are doing from not only an air perspective, but also across the different domains is something that it's challenging.

00:11:28: And in particular with Europe you've got a myriad nations have different capabilities and importantly one key challenge first having shared understanding common operational picture of what is happening, and then how do we integrate an inter-operate between the nations to be able to defend each individual nation but collectively Europe as a whole?

00:11:58: And that's a challenge.

00:12:00: What I would highlight—that bit is significant improvement over time–is the amount of exercises how the nations work together from not only an air component perspective, but are also working to integrate uh...the other domains.

00:12:19: To be part of that defense for the nation.

00:12:22: and those are challenges that um i think have been well acknowledged But require constant communication, constant training to ensure everyone is operating at high levels.

00:12:38: You had a lot of experiences as commander.

00:12:40: How would you say is the exchange data in Europe or within NATO states?

00:12:47: Yeah, so that was an area I spent time working through and what i will share with you has unfortunate.

00:12:59: as Russian invasion of Ukraine it drove information sharing to another level.

00:13:06: we had to be sure that, you know collectively We understood What they were doing and then sharing that information not only at the strategic level But down to the operational and tactical levels so that we could number one posture our forces to be in the right position And then ensure that You know if a response was required.

00:13:32: We were in the appropriate Locations have the necessary airplanes, airborne to defend the nations.

00:13:41: Challenges remain though and this is an area that as you look at the policies that each nation has um...to protect The critical data that may be out there.

00:13:54: That is something that needs to be continually worked at.

00:13:58: It's constantly changing And nations are going to have specific requirements that they're gonna have to think their way through in terms of how much they are willing to share.

00:14:11: I would say given global security and the environment we work today, nations has become more willing.

00:14:29: Needs to be continually worked because there's always a dynamic they're and as the world changes We need to be able to adapt of that, and it's hard.

00:14:37: It takes time And we don't want to have a Significant event happen That could've prevented had we shared the information.

00:14:47: so I think from me The operator or warfighters perspective That requirement is clear, but as you get into the political environment and those types of discussions that's an area we need to continue.

00:15:01: Continue the conversation have those discussions work through it in a way that facilitates collective understanding so important not only deterring and defending by being able respond at appropriate time

00:15:16: line.".

00:15:18: Do You Like This Podcast?

00:15:20: Militaire Actuelle Is Also Available In Print.

00:15:23: The Austrian Military Magazine is published four times a year and reports on security policy issues, the Austrian Armed Forces and the international defence industry.

00:15:33: You will receive regular updates via our newsletter – On our social media channels And of course on our website.

00:15:40: Visit militiaaktuell.at.

00:15:46: Let's talk about integrated air and missile defense.

00:15:50: Could you walk us through a concrete scenario?

00:15:53: And explain what needs to work together from detection to interception, which role fighter jets play?

00:16:00: Well we may need a couple of hours to have that discussion but I'll give you my My three-minute answer because as you think about Integrated Air and Missile Defense It really starts with.

00:16:14: and let's just.

00:16:16: you know, I kind of talked about it up front.

00:16:17: You've got a theater beneath ballistic missile defense.

00:16:22: Or Let's use the example of some of the drone Scenarios that have occurred in the Middle East.

00:16:28: You see them incurring in Ukraine now on almost a daily basis.

00:16:32: And how would you approach?

00:16:33: That.

00:16:34: so first um is going to start with indications and warnings using The broader intelligence environment that's out there to get a sense of what potentially could happen in the near future.

00:16:47: Leveraging that, as you talked about how would you first sense it?

00:16:54: In other words have domain awareness and I don't mean just an error—you'd also want from space to see or even undersea to understand posture ourselves appropriately.

00:17:13: That could be airplanes in a combat air patrol, it will talk about CCAs later but collaborative combat aircraft doing that kind of mission to find and fix the particular targets.

00:17:30: so if we're talking lots You're typically gonna have an ability to first, have some sensing of when they get launched.

00:17:41: And now you're going look at okay depending upon how we were postured who do you commit from an asset perspective i.e what number of airplanes to go out and target those particular threats?

00:17:54: Now I said it earlier but I'm just gonna reinforce typically want a layer defense so that forward echelon That's going to take out some number of targets, and then if there is as we would describe them leakers that get by you.

00:18:09: Would have either airplanes farther back or You hand those particular targets off?

00:18:16: To a surface-to air capability ie a patriot There are some other capabilities that are all they're now from a counter UAS perspective.

00:18:28: you would ask me, well, um, Cobra how does that happen?

00:18:33: This is through training.

00:18:35: Um leveraging what we typically call battle management where either an airplane

00:18:43: i.e.,

00:18:43: uh potentially like a F- Thirty five would know that it target has gotten by maybe because We don't have enough weapons or not enough airplanes and now You hand It off to That particular Target To the surface to air entity that would now pick up, I see that track and then go after it.

00:19:04: And that's typically how we close the kill chain.

00:19:08: as you would expect The more targets are out there the more complex It gets in a requirement to go out and train and practice these handoffs and ensure That number one We're finding them fixing them and targeting with right equipment Because you don't want to, to the extent possible take shots at the same target.

00:19:32: In other words we only have so many weapons and we need to optimize those weapons... ...and do that through the battle management I just talked about.

00:19:40: Ultimately then what your gonna do is assess Hey did we get them all?

00:19:45: Do We Need To Execute Any Other Handoffs?

00:19:48: And as you can imagine, it's a very dynamic scenario that depending upon the threat and how many targets are out there.

00:19:55: That we have to continually work this... ...and then manage not only the number of airplanes they're born but where do you have air planes with weapons?

00:20:04: Or those folks on the ground who would be in-game defense for playing into these scenarios?

00:20:10: well So hopefully that helps keep it somewhat clear from The dynamics of an environment like that what it would take to close at That kill chain and multiple kill chains in an integrated in their missile defense scenario.

00:20:28: How would you answer someone if he asks why do we need manned aircraft or fighter jets?

00:20:34: when?

00:20:35: We witness the rise of UAVs.

00:20:38: so right now I Would say this, you know the key piece of this particular problem set is where do the humans ultimately make the decision to employ a weapon?

00:20:52: And, you know currently today we are all learning quickly about the capabilities.

00:21:00: We can talk about collaborative combat aircraft in the autonomy associated with them.

00:21:07: Each scenario would be different, but if we were to talk through a European scenario you could envision one where we have some CCAs that are forward.

00:21:19: That can work at initial sensing the indications and warnings.

00:21:23: But If You're Going To Have Them Employ Weapons You're Gonna Want To Have Today I Would Offer A Human In The Loop Now what that does afford, you could have a human either operating it say from an F-thirty five fifty sixty miles back.

00:21:39: where now if you think about the risk to that particular CCA well.

00:21:44: You go okay I don't have uh...a person in that airplane so i can buy more risk than I would If I had a person up forward?

00:21:54: and has we develop, and I say we because it will not only be the operators in warfighters but i think also We'll have to make our politician and senior leaders of nations comfortable with what autonomy means.

00:22:10: How do we have trust and confidence?

00:22:12: And What that particular CCA or UAV is doing To execute that intercept and shoot at the appropriate target that we wanted to shoot It.

00:22:24: so That's going to take time.

00:22:26: It will take years and it'll take several, not only training.

00:22:33: And I don't want to call them experiments but those types of things where we go out and practice a learn an understand what the vehicle is doing?

00:22:45: And then understand okay when we tell that target something does it do What We Say?

00:22:50: now?

00:22:50: i think That Day Will Come.

00:22:57: Where do we want to buy the risk?

00:22:59: And arguably, you know put humans into an opportunity in a environment where they have the best opportunities go out and execute their mission.

00:23:09: And clearly survive come back home again.

00:23:13: so there will be times.

00:23:14: I think that it'll make complete sense when seeing some of this were on unmanned vehicle what's required recognizing may lose but didn't loose person.

00:23:26: So that discussion, the learning that will be ongoing I believe over the next couple of years is we better gain that trust and confidence in these unmanned vehicles.

00:23:40: And point to be talked about a little bit.

00:23:45: while we were in the Air Force called them remotely piloted vehicles for awhile was because wanted make sure people understood We had to make decisions on when a weapon would be expended.

00:23:58: And so as autonomy continues to improve, mature at some point it's hard to predict when that will be I think we'll find times that it will be acceptable At all levels of leadership to execute with that type of mentality.

00:24:16: So there is no doubt CCA will come but It will take many years until this mass phenomena.

00:24:23: I'll

00:24:24: go back to my two words of trust and confidence in CCAs, that they do what we ask them to.

00:24:31: And then as autonomy gets more mature... ...that they respond appropriately whatever algorithms are placed there.

00:24:43: There will be different ways for me to manage it.

00:24:49: a human could, as you...you can envision target something and tell the vehicle hey go target that particular thing.

00:24:57: And then once it's executed it just returns home.

00:25:00: but I think what we'll learn over time is there may be other ways to leverage vehicles.

00:25:08: maybe our grandkids will figure out.

00:25:10: has the autonomy gets better and in the particular vehicles to do what we've directed them, or actually programmed into the algorithms.

00:25:22: You mentioned several times that F-serty five this jet could be an option for the Austrian armed forces.

00:25:30: What are key features of that jet?

00:25:33: Well first off I would tell you from a lockheed perspective Having been an f-twenty two pilot previously the F thirty five takes many of The lessons that we learned in the F twenty to from a sensor fusion integration Of More sensors that allow not only I won't get too technical here, but our spectrum But also the electrical optical Spectrum and then integrate that into A single track for the pilot.

00:26:09: then can be shared across all the domains.

00:26:13: So while I thought we had a significant advantage in the F-twenty two, BF thirty five has taken it to another level.

00:26:21: so you know as I see this as something that takes not only your air component to the next level,

00:26:33: i.e.,

00:26:33: a fifth-generation Air Force but also will uplift your other domains—your land domain in particular because the capability will not only take information it sees increased capability to make smart decisions and employ in a manner that they previously have been unable to do.

00:27:00: And what I would highlight Tia is, um In particular over the last year where The United States Air Force has been able to employ the airplane Um in real world combat environments not just in training.

00:27:15: This has been demonstrated day-in and day out.

00:27:21: Two terms here, one is risk to the mission success.

00:27:27: And so what they have found key to mission success is leveraging F-thirty fives for the exact reasons I just defined.

00:27:34: The second piece we talk about is risks of force and that is a risk to particular people who are actually flying in an airplane.

00:27:41: So when you have this amount information You now can not only leverage your collective team of F-ThirtyFives, but share that with others to ensure you're making timely smart decisions not only be lethal in how you employ and also improve your survivability.

00:28:04: And make the entire team better as we go out and employ these real world missions.

00:28:14: I've personally received from multiple folks flying F- Thirty-Fives downrange.

00:28:19: And so, you know collectively as i said if you look at it uh...from a national perspective ...I would offer that's going to provide you and your nation..your population huge advantage for both the deterrent ..and defense perspective.

00:28:35: And against more countries introduced to F-Thirty-Five higher than kind of network effect.

00:28:41: Yeah, um one of the uh The beauties of the f- Thirty five and the numbers that you would have across Europe Which is going to be?

00:28:48: You know in the next couple years here upward of seven hundred F. Thirty five's across europe That interoperability from not only a maintenance perspective A operator perspective, you know the tactics techniques and procedures.

00:29:05: But what we found Is that as more nations come into the family, you know are now on the team.

00:29:15: The better the interoperability is improved because not only are they communicating with each other but that's happening at all levels—all the way from the operational understanding of how to employ a thirty-fives but down into the tactical level where squadrons are talking the lessons they've learned, how they share them and then ultimately how their able to employ almost seamlessly across all of Europe.

00:29:43: And I think that's a huge advantage for The Nation... ...and frankly for European security!

00:29:49: Okay thanks for the possibility to talk with you.

00:29:51: Thanks for your precious time on AllTheBest for the SkunkWorks program.

00:29:56: Yeah thank Steph and i appreciate it.

00:29:58: Thank You For Your Time.

00:30:00: We look forward to collaborating with y'all going forward

00:30:03: And see you soon in Teltweeg.

00:30:06: All right, sounds good!

00:30:07: Thank you very much.

00:30:08: we'll talk to you later.

00:30:19: Bye bye.

Neuer Kommentar

Dein Name oder Pseudonym (wird öffentlich angezeigt)
Mindestens 10 Zeichen
Durch das Abschicken des Formulars stimmst du zu, dass der Wert unter "Name oder Pseudonym" gespeichert wird und öffentlich angezeigt werden kann. Wir speichern keine IP-Adressen oder andere personenbezogene Daten. Die Nutzung deines echten Namens ist freiwillig.